Reedle Откройте в мобильном приложении
Понятно
Понятно
Для того чтобы воспользоваться закладками, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Для того чтобы воспользоваться озвучкой предложений, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Озвучка предложений доступна при наличии PRO-доступа
Купить PRO-доступ
Отмена
On
the
twenty-fourth
the
weather
cleared
up
after
a
spell
of
rain
,
and
after
dinner
Pierre
left
Moscow
.
When
changing
horses
that
night
in
Perkhúshkovo
,
he
learned
that
there
had
been
a
great
battle
that
evening
.
(
This
was
the
battle
of
Shevárdino
.
)
He
was
told
that
there
in
Perkhúshkovo
the
earth
trembled
from
the
firing
,
but
nobody
could
answer
his
questions
as
to
who
had
won
.
At
dawn
next
day
Pierre
was
approaching
Mozháysk
.
Every
house
in
Mozháysk
had
soldiers
quartered
in
it
,
and
at
the
hostel
where
Pierre
was
met
by
his
groom
and
coachman
there
was
no
room
to
be
had
.
It
was
full
of
officers
Everywhere
in
Mozháysk
and
beyond
it
,
troops
were
stationed
or
on
the
march
.
Cossacks
,
foot
and
horse
soldiers
,
wagons
,
caissons
,
and
cannon
were
everywhere
.
Pierre
pushed
forward
as
fast
as
he
could
,
and
the
farther
he
left
Moscow
behind
and
the
deeper
he
plunged
into
that
sea
of
troops
the
more
was
he
overcome
by
restless
agitation
and
a
new
and
joyful
feeling
he
had
not
experienced
before
.
It
was
a
feeling
akin
to
what
he
had
felt
at
the
Slobóda
Palace
during
the
Emperor
's
visit
--
a
sense
of
the
necessity
of
undertaking
something
and
sacrificing
something
.
He
now
experienced
a
glad
consciousness
that
everything
that
constitutes
men
's
happiness
--
the
comforts
of
life
,
wealth
,
even
life
itself
--
is
rubbish
it
is
pleasant
to
throw
away
,
compared
with
something
...
With
what
?
Pierre
could
not
say
,
and
he
did
not
try
to
determine
for
whom
and
for
what
he
felt
such
particular
delight
in
sacrificing
everything
.
He
was
not
occupied
with
the
question
of
what
to
sacrifice
for
;
the
fact
of
sacrificing
in
itself
afforded
him
a
new
and
joyous
sensation
.
Отключить рекламу
On
the
twenty-fourth
of
August
the
battle
of
the
Shevárdino
Redoubt
was
fought
,
on
the
twenty-fifth
not
a
shot
was
fired
by
either
side
,
and
on
the
twenty-sixth
the
battle
of
Borodinó
itself
took
place
.
Why
and
how
were
the
battles
of
Shevárdino
and
Borodinó
given
and
accepted
?
Why
was
the
battle
of
Borodinó
fought
?
There
was
not
the
least
sense
in
it
for
either
the
French
or
the
Russians
.
Its
immediate
result
for
the
Russians
was
,
and
was
bound
to
be
,
that
we
were
brought
nearer
to
the
destruction
of
Moscow
--
which
we
feared
more
than
anything
in
the
world
;
and
for
the
French
its
immediate
result
was
that
they
were
brought
nearer
to
the
destruction
of
their
whole
army
--
which
they
feared
more
than
anything
in
the
world
.
What
the
result
must
be
was
quite
obvious
,
and
yet
Napoleon
offered
and
Kutúzov
accepted
that
battle
.
If
the
commanders
had
been
guided
by
reason
,
it
would
seem
that
it
must
have
been
obvious
to
Napoleon
that
by
advancing
thirteen
hundred
miles
and
giving
battle
with
a
probability
of
losing
a
quarter
of
his
army
,
he
was
advancing
to
certain
destruction
,
and
it
must
have
been
equally
clear
to
Kutúzov
that
by
accepting
battle
and
risking
the
loss
of
a
quarter
of
his
army
he
would
certainly
lose
Moscow
.
For
Kutúzov
this
was
mathematically
clear
,
as
it
is
that
if
when
playing
draughts
I
have
one
man
less
and
go
on
exchanging
,
I
shall
certainly
lose
,
and
therefore
should
not
exchange
.
When
my
opponent
has
sixteen
men
and
I
have
fourteen
,
I
am
only
one
eighth
weaker
than
he
,
but
when
I
have
exchanged
thirteen
more
men
he
will
be
three
times
as
strong
as
I
am
.
Before
the
battle
of
Borodinó
our
strength
in
proportion
to
the
French
was
about
as
five
to
six
,
but
after
that
battle
it
was
little
more
than
one
to
two
:
previously
we
had
a
hundred
thousand
against
a
hundred
and
twenty
thousand
;
afterwards
little
more
than
fifty
thousand
against
a
hundred
thousand
.
Yet
the
shrewd
and
experienced
Kutúzov
accepted
the
battle
,
while
Napoleon
,
who
was
said
to
be
a
commander
of
genius
,
gave
it
,
losing
a
quarter
of
his
army
and
lengthening
his
lines
of
communication
still
more
.
If
it
is
said
that
he
expected
to
end
the
campaign
by
occupying
Moscow
as
he
had
ended
a
previous
campaign
by
occupying
Vienna
,
there
is
much
evidence
to
the
contrary
.
Napoleon
's
historians
themselves
tell
us
that
from
Smolénsk
onwards
he
wished
to
stop
,
knew
the
danger
of
his
extended
position
,
and
knew
that
the
occupation
of
Moscow
would
not
be
the
end
of
the
campaign
,
for
he
had
seen
at
Smolénsk
the
state
in
which
Russian
towns
were
left
to
him
,
and
had
not
received
a
single
reply
to
his
repeated
announcements
of
his
wish
to
negotiate
.
Отключить рекламу
In
giving
and
accepting
battle
at
Borodinó
,
Kutúzov
acted
involuntarily
and
irrationally
.
But
later
on
,
to
fit
what
had
occurred
,
the
historians
provided
cunningly
devised
evidence
of
the
foresight
and
genius
of
the
generals
who
,
of
all
the
blind
tools
of
history
were
the
most
enslaved
and
involuntary
.
The
ancients
have
left
us
model
heroic
poems
in
which
the
heroes
furnish
the
whole
interest
of
the
story
,
and
we
are
still
unable
to
accustom
ourselves
to
the
fact
that
for
our
epoch
histories
of
that
kind
are
meaningless
.
On
the
other
question
,
how
the
battle
of
Borodinó
and
the
preceding
battle
of
Shevárdino
were
fought
,
there
also
exists
a
definite
and
well-known
,
but
quite
false
,
conception
.
All
the
historians
describe
the
affair
as
follows
: