Reedle Откройте в мобильном приложении
Понятно
Понятно
Для того чтобы воспользоваться закладками, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Для того чтобы воспользоваться озвучкой предложений, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Озвучка предложений доступна при наличии PRO-доступа
Купить PRO-доступ
Отмена
The
porter
and
Koch
and
Pestryakov
and
the
other
porter
and
the
wife
of
the
first
porter
and
the
woman
who
was
sitting
in
the
porter
’
s
lodge
and
the
man
Kryukov
,
who
had
just
got
out
of
a
cab
at
that
minute
and
went
in
at
the
entry
with
a
lady
on
his
arm
,
that
is
eight
or
ten
witnesses
,
agree
that
Nikolay
had
Dmitri
on
the
ground
,
was
lying
on
him
beating
him
,
while
Dmitri
hung
on
to
his
hair
,
beating
him
,
too
.
They
lay
right
across
the
way
,
blocking
the
thoroughfare
.
They
were
sworn
at
on
all
sides
while
they
‘
like
children
’
(
the
very
words
of
the
witnesses
)
were
falling
over
one
another
,
squealing
,
fighting
and
laughing
with
the
funniest
faces
,
and
,
chasing
one
another
like
children
,
they
ran
into
the
street
.
Now
take
careful
note
.
The
bodies
upstairs
were
warm
,
you
understand
,
warm
when
they
found
them
!
If
they
,
or
Nikolay
alone
,
had
murdered
them
and
broken
open
the
boxes
,
or
simply
taken
part
in
the
robbery
,
allow
me
to
ask
you
one
question
:
do
their
state
of
mind
,
their
squeals
and
giggles
and
childish
scuffling
at
the
gate
fit
in
with
axes
,
bloodshed
,
fiendish
cunning
,
robbery
?
They
’
d
just
killed
them
,
not
five
or
ten
minutes
before
,
for
the
bodies
were
still
warm
,
and
at
once
,
leaving
the
flat
open
,
knowing
that
people
would
go
there
at
once
,
flinging
away
their
booty
,
they
rolled
about
like
children
,
laughing
and
attracting
general
attention
.
And
there
are
a
dozen
witnesses
to
swear
to
that
!
”
“
Of
course
it
is
strange
!
It
’
s
impossible
,
indeed
,
but
.
.
.
”
“
No
,
brother
,
no
buts
.
Отключить рекламу
And
if
the
ear
-
rings
being
found
in
Nikolay
’
s
hands
at
the
very
day
and
hour
of
the
murder
constitutes
an
important
piece
of
circumstantial
evidence
against
him
—
although
the
explanation
given
by
him
accounts
for
it
,
and
therefore
it
does
not
tell
seriously
against
him
—
one
must
take
into
consideration
the
facts
which
prove
him
innocent
,
especially
as
they
are
facts
that
cannot
be
denied
.
And
do
you
suppose
,
from
the
character
of
our
legal
system
,
that
they
will
accept
,
or
that
they
are
in
a
position
to
accept
,
this
fact
—
resting
simply
on
a
psychological
impossibility
—
as
irrefutable
and
conclusively
breaking
down
the
circumstantial
evidence
for
the
prosecution
?
No
,
they
won
’
t
accept
it
,
they
certainly
won
’
t
,
because
they
found
the
jewel
-
case
and
the
man
tried
to
hang
himself
,
‘
which
he
could
not
have
done
if
he
hadn
’
t
felt
guilty
.
’
That
’
s
the
point
,
that
’
s
what
excites
me
,
you
must
understand
!
”
“
Oh
,
I
see
you
are
excited
!
Wait
a
bit
.
I
forgot
to
ask
you
;
what
proof
is
there
that
the
box
came
from
the
old
woman
?
”
“
That
’
s
been
proved
,
”
said
Razumihin
with
apparent
reluctance
,
frowning
.
“
Koch
recognised
the
jewel
-
case
and
gave
the
name
of
the
owner
,
who
proved
conclusively
that
it
was
his
.
”
“
That
’
s
bad
.
Now
another
point
.
Did
anyone
see
Nikolay
at
the
time
that
Koch
and
Pestryakov
were
going
upstairs
at
first
,
and
is
there
no
evidence
about
that
?
”
Отключить рекламу
“
Nobody
did
see
him
,
”
Razumihin
answered
with
vexation
.
“
That
’
s
the
worst
of
it
.
Even
Koch
and
Pestryakov
did
not
notice
them
on
their
way
upstairs
,
though
,
indeed
,
their
evidence
could
not
have
been
worth
much
.
They
said
they
saw
the
flat
was
open
,
and
that
there
must
be
work
going
on
in
it
,
but
they
took
no
special
notice
and
could
not
remember
whether
there
actually
were
men
at
work
in
it
.
”
“
Hm
!
.
.
.
So
the
only
evidence
for
the
defence
is
that
they
were
beating
one
another
and
laughing
.
That
constitutes
a
strong
presumption
,
but
.
.
.
How
do
you
explain
the
facts
yourself
?
”