Reedle Откройте в мобильном приложении
Понятно
Понятно
Для того чтобы воспользоваться закладками, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Для того чтобы воспользоваться озвучкой предложений, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Озвучка предложений доступна при наличии PRO-доступа
Купить PRO-доступ
Отмена
71
"
Paul
Dumas
,
physician
,
deposes
that
he
was
called
to
view
the
bodies
about
day-break
.
They
were
both
then
lying
on
the
sacking
of
the
bedstead
in
the
chamber
where
Mademoiselle
L.
was
found
.
The
corpse
of
the
young
lady
was
much
bruised
and
excoriated
.
The
fact
that
it
had
been
thrust
up
the
chimney
would
sufficiently
account
for
these
appearances
.
The
throat
was
greatly
chafed
.
There
were
several
deep
scratches
just
below
the
chin
,
together
with
a
series
of
livid
spots
which
were
evidently
the
impression
of
fingers
.
The
face
was
fearfully
discolored
,
and
the
eye-balls
protruded
.
The
tongue
had
been
partially
bitten
through
.
A
large
bruise
was
discovered
upon
the
pit
of
the
stomach
,
produced
,
apparently
,
by
the
pressure
of
a
knee
.
In
the
opinion
of
M.
Dumas
,
Mademoiselle
L'Espanaye
had
been
throttled
to
death
by
some
person
or
persons
unknown
.
The
corpse
of
the
mother
was
horribly
mutilated
.
All
the
bones
of
the
right
leg
and
arm
were
more
or
less
shattered
.
The
left
tibia
much
splintered
,
as
well
as
all
the
ribs
of
the
left
side
.
Whole
body
dreadfully
bruised
and
discolored
.
It
was
not
possible
to
say
how
the
injuries
had
been
inflicted
.
72
A
heavy
club
of
wood
,
or
a
broad
bar
of
iron
--
a
chair
--
any
large
,
heavy
,
and
obtuse
weapon
have
produced
such
results
,
if
wielded
by
the
hands
of
a
very
powerful
man
.
No
woman
could
have
inflicted
the
blows
with
any
weapon
.
The
head
of
the
deceased
,
when
seen
by
witness
,
was
entirely
separated
from
the
body
,
and
was
also
greatly
shattered
.
The
throat
had
evidently
been
cut
with
some
very
sharp
instrument
--
probably
with
a
razor
.
73
"
Alexandre
Etienne
,
surgeon
,
was
called
with
M.
Dumas
to
view
the
bodies
.
Corroborated
the
testimony
,
and
the
opinions
of
M.
Dumas
.
Отключить рекламу
74
"
Nothing
farther
of
importance
was
elicited
,
although
several
other
persons
were
examined
.
A
murder
so
mysterious
,
and
so
perplexing
in
all
its
particulars
,
was
never
before
committed
in
Paris
--
if
indeed
a
murder
has
been
committed
at
all
.
The
police
are
entirely
at
fault
--
an
unusual
occurrence
in
affairs
of
this
nature
.
There
is
not
,
however
,
the
shadow
of
a
clew
apparent
.
"
The
evening
edition
of
the
paper
stated
that
the
greatest
excitement
continued
in
the
Quartier
St.
Roch
--
that
the
premises
in
question
had
been
carefully
re-searched
,
and
fresh
examinations
of
witnesses
instituted
,
but
all
to
no
purpose
.
A
postscript
,
however
mentioned
that
Adolphe
Le
Bon
had
been
arrested
and
imprisoned
--
although
nothing
appeared
to
criminate
him
,
beyond
the
facts
already
detailed
.
75
Dupin
seemed
singularly
interested
in
the
progress
of
this
affair
--
at
least
so
I
judged
from
his
manner
,
for
he
made
no
comments
.
76
It
was
only
after
the
announcement
that
Le
Bon
had
been
imprisoned
,
that
he
asked
me
my
opinion
respecting
the
murders
.
77
I
could
merely
agree
with
all
Paris
in
considering
them
an
insoluble
mystery
.
I
saw
no
means
by
which
it
would
be
possible
to
trace
the
murderer
.
Отключить рекламу
78
"
We
must
not
judge
of
the
means
,
"
said
Dupin
,
"
by
this
shell
of
an
examination
.
The
Parisian
police
,
so
much
extolled
for
acumen
,
are
cunning
,
but
no
more
.
There
is
no
method
in
their
proceedings
,
beyond
the
method
of
the
moment
.
They
make
a
vast
parade
of
measures
;
but
,
not
unfrequently
,
these
are
so
ill
adapted
to
the
objects
proposed
,
as
to
put
us
in
mind
of
Monsieur
Jourdain
's
calling
for
his
robe-de-chambre
--
pour
mieux
entendre
la
musique
.
The
results
attained
by
them
are
not
unfrequently
surprising
,
but
,
for
the
most
part
,
are
brought
about
by
simple
diligence
and
activity
.
When
these
qualities
are
unavailing
,
their
schemes
fall
.
Vidocq
,
for
example
,
was
a
good
guesser
,
and
a
persevering
man
.
But
,
without
educated
thought
,
he
erred
continually
by
the
very
intensity
of
his
investigations
.
He
impaired
his
vision
by
holding
the
object
too
close
.
He
might
see
,
perhaps
,
one
or
two
points
with
unusual
clearness
,
but
in
so
doing
he
,
necessarily
,
lost
sight
of
the
matter
as
a
whole
.
Thus
there
is
such
a
thing
as
being
too
profound
.
Truth
is
not
always
in
a
well
.
In
fact
,
as
regards
the
more
important
knowledge
,
I
do
believe
that
she
is
invariably
superficial
.
The
depth
lies
in
the
valleys
where
we
seek
her
,
and
not
upon
the
mountain-tops
where
she
is
found
.
79
The
modes
and
sources
of
this
kind
of
error
are
well
typified
in
the
contemplation
of
the
heavenly
bodies
.
To
look
at
a
star
by
glances
--
to
view
it
in
a
side-long
way
,
by
turning
toward
it
the
exterior
portions
of
the
retina
(
more
susceptible
of
feeble
impressions
of
light
than
the
interior
)
,
is
to
behold
the
star
distinctly
--
is
to
have
the
best
appreciation
of
its
lustre
--
a
lustre
which
grows
dim
just
in
proportion
as
we
turn
our
vision
fully
upon
it
.
A
greater
number
of
rays
actually
fall
upon
the
eye
in
the
latter
case
,
but
,
in
the
former
,
there
is
the
more
refined
capacity
for
comprehension
.
By
undue
profundity
we
perplex
and
enfeeble
thought
;
and
it
is
possible
to
make
even
Venus
herself
vanish
from
the
firmament
by
a
scrutiny
too
sustained
,
too
concentrated
,
or
too
direct
.
80
"
As
for
these
murders
,
let
us
enter
into
some
examinations
for
ourselves
,
before
we
make
up
an
opinion
respecting
them
.
An
inquiry
will
afford
us
amusement
,
"
(
I
thought
this
an
odd
term
,
so
applied
,
but
said
nothing
)
"
and
,
besides
,
Le
Bon
once
rendered
me
a
service
for
which
I
am
not
ungrateful
.
We
will
go
and
see
the
premises
with
our
own
eyes
.
I
know
G
--
the
Prefect
of
Police
,
and
shall
have
no
difficulty
in
obtaining
the
necessary
permission
.
"