Reedle Откройте в мобильном приложении
Понятно
Понятно
Для того чтобы воспользоваться закладками, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Для того чтобы воспользоваться озвучкой предложений, необходимо
Войти или зарегистрироваться
Отмена
Озвучка предложений доступна при наличии PRO-доступа
Купить PRO-доступ
Отмена
31
But
Iluvatar
knew
that
Men
,
being
set
amid
the
turmoils
of
the
powers
of
the
world
,
would
stray
often
,
and
would
not
use
their
gifts
in
harmony
;
and
he
said
:
These
too
in
their
time
shall
find
that
all
that
they
do
redounds
at
the
end
only
to
the
glory
of
my
work
.
Yet
the
Elves
believe
that
Men
are
often
a
grief
to
Manwe
,
who
knows
most
of
the
mind
of
Iluvatar
;
for
it
seems
to
the
Elves
that
Men
resemble
Melkor
most
of
all
the
Ainur
,
although
he
has
ever
feared
and
hated
them
,
even
those
that
served
him
.
32
It
is
one
with
this
gift
of
freedom
that
the
children
of
Men
dwell
only
a
short
space
in
the
world
alive
,
and
are
not
bound
to
it
,
and
depart
soon
whither
the
Elves
know
not
.
Whereas
the
Elves
remain
until
the
end
of
days
,
and
their
love
of
the
Earth
and
all
the
world
is
more
single
and
more
poignant
therefore
,
and
as
the
years
lengthen
ever
more
sorrowful
.
For
the
Elves
die
not
till
tile
world
dies
,
unless
they
are
slain
or
waste
in
grief
(
and
to
both
these
seeming
deaths
they
are
subject
)
;
neither
does
age
subdue
their
strength
,
unless
one
grow
weary
of
ten
thousand
centuries
;
and
dying
they
are
gathered
to
the
halls
of
Mandos
in
Valinor
,
whence
they
may
in
time
return
.
But
the
sons
of
Men
die
indeed
,
and
leave
the
world
;
wherefore
they
are
called
the
Guests
,
or
the
Strangers
.
Death
is
their
fate
,
the
gift
of
Iluvatar
,
which
as
Time
wears
even
the
Powers
shall
envy
.
33
But
Melkor
has
cast
his
shadow
upon
it
,
and
confounded
it
with
darkness
,
and
brought
forth
evil
out
of
good
,
and
fear
out
of
hope
.
Yet
of
old
the
Valar
declared
to
the
Elves
in
Valinor
that
Men
shall
join
in
the
Second
Music
of
the
Ainur
;
whereas
Iluvatar
has
hot
revealed
what
he
purposes
for
the
Elves
after
the
World
s
end
,
and
Melkor
has
not
discovered
it
.
Отключить рекламу
34
It
is
told
that
in
their
beginning
the
Dwarves
were
made
by
Aule
in
the
darkness
of
Middle
-
earth
;
for
so
greatly
did
Aule
desire
the
coming
of
the
Children
,
to
have
learners
to
whom
he
could
teach
his
lore
and
his
crafts
,
that
he
was
unwilling
to
await
the
fulfilment
of
the
designs
of
Iluvatar
.
And
Aule
made
the
Dwarves
even
as
they
still
are
,
because
the
forms
of
the
Children
who
were
to
come
were
unclear
to
his
mind
,
and
because
the
power
of
Melkor
was
yet
over
the
Earth
;
and
he
wished
therefore
that
they
should
be
strong
and
unyielding
.
But
fearing
that
the
other
Valar
might
blame
his
work
,
he
wrought
in
secret
:
and
he
made
first
the
Seven
Fathers
of
the
Dwarves
in
a
hall
under
the
mountains
in
Middle
-
earth
.
35
Now
Iluvatar
knew
what
was
done
,
and
in
the
very
hour
that
Aule
s
work
was
complete
,
and
he
was
pleased
,
and
began
to
instruct
the
Dwarves
in
the
speech
that
he
had
devised
for
them
,
Iluvatar
spoke
to
him
;
and
Aule
heard
his
voice
and
was
silent
.
And
the
voice
of
Iluvatar
said
to
him
:
Why
hast
thou
done
this
?
Why
dost
thou
attempt
a
thing
which
thou
knowest
is
beyond
thy
power
and
thy
authority
?
For
thou
hast
from
me
as
a
gift
thy
own
bring
only
,
and
no
more
;
and
therefore
the
creatures
of
thy
hand
and
mind
can
live
only
by
that
being
,
moving
when
thou
thinkest
to
move
them
,
and
if
thy
thought
be
elsewhere
,
standing
idle
.
Is
that
thy
desire
?
36
Then
Aule
answered
:
I
did
not
desire
such
lordship
.
I
desired
things
other
than
I
am
,
to
love
and
to
teach
them
,
so
that
they
too
might
perceive
the
beauty
of
Ea
,
which
thou
hast
caused
to
be
.
For
it
seemed
to
me
that
there
is
great
room
in
Arda
for
many
things
that
might
rejoice
in
it
,
yet
it
is
for
the
most
part
empty
still
,
and
dumb
.
And
in
my
impatience
I
have
fallen
into
folly
.
37
Yet
the
making
of
thing
is
in
my
heart
from
my
own
making
by
thee
;
and
the
child
of
little
understanding
that
makes
a
play
of
the
deeds
of
his
father
may
do
so
without
thought
of
mockery
,
but
because
he
is
the
son
of
his
father
.
But
what
shall
I
do
now
,
so
that
thou
be
not
angry
with
me
for
ever
?
As
a
child
to
his
father
,
I
offer
to
thee
these
things
,
the
work
of
the
hands
which
thou
hast
made
.
Do
with
them
what
thou
wilt
.
But
should
I
not
rather
destroy
the
work
of
my
presumption
?
Отключить рекламу
38
Then
Aule
took
up
a
great
hammer
to
smite
the
Dwarves
;
and
he
wept
.
But
Iluvatar
had
compassion
upon
Aule
and
his
desire
,
because
of
his
humility
;
and
the
Dwarves
shrank
from
the
hammer
and
wore
afraid
,
and
they
bowed
down
their
heads
and
begged
for
mercy
.
And
the
voice
of
Iluvatar
said
to
Aule
:
Thy
offer
I
accepted
even
as
it
was
made
.
Dost
thou
not
see
that
these
things
have
now
a
life
of
their
own
,
and
speak
with
their
own
voices
?
Else
they
would
not
have
flinched
from
thy
blow
,
nor
from
any
command
of
thy
will
.
Then
Aule
cast
down
his
hammer
and
was
glad
,
and
he
gave
thanks
to
Iluvatar
,
saying
:
May
Eru
bless
my
work
and
amend
it
!
39
But
Iluvatar
spoke
again
and
said
:
Even
as
I
gave
being
to
the
thoughts
of
the
Ainur
at
the
beginning
of
the
World
,
so
now
I
have
taken
up
thy
desire
and
given
to
it
a
place
therein
;
but
in
no
other
way
will
I
amend
thy
handiwork
,
and
as
thou
hast
made
it
,
so
shall
it
be
.
But
I
will
not
suffer
this
:
that
these
should
come
before
the
Firstborn
of
my
design
,
nor
that
thy
impatience
should
be
rewarded
.
They
shall
sleep
now
in
the
darkness
under
stone
,
and
shall
not
come
forth
until
the
Firstborn
have
awakened
upon
Earth
;
and
until
that
time
thou
and
they
shall
wait
,
though
long
it
seem
.
40
But
when
the
time
comes
I
will
awaken
them
,
and
they
shall
be
to
thee
as
children
;
and
often
strife
shall
arise
between
thine
and
mine
,
the
children
of
my
adoption
and
the
children
of
my
choice
.